And America’s favorite Halloween candy is…

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

Credit: Influenster

Credit: Influenster

Credit: Influenster

Sometimes the expected is better than a surprise. At least when it comes to candy.

Influenster.com, a product review website, polled 40,000 people to determine America’s favorite Halloween candy, state-by-state.

Overall, the most highly-voted candy was Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups–which also happens to be Connecticut’s favorite sweet!–while the overall favorite candy for the most number of states was candy corn (Oregon, Wyoming, Tennessee, Texas and South Carolina).

So the overall takeaway is if you’re heading to the store to buy candy to hand out on Halloween night, your safest bet is to buy a mega-sized bag of Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, or at least the miniature ones.

Only 26 states picked candies with a chocolate base, while the others favored the more pure forms of sugar.

Related: Most popular Halloween costumes in every state

Unsurprisingly, no states picked non-candy treats as their favorite trick-or-treating surprise.

“Halloween is every American’s favorite fall holiday,” Aydin Acar, cofounder and CEO of Influenster, told Yahoo Parenting.

Here’s a breakdown of each state’s favorite treat:

Alabama: AirHeads
Alaska: Snickers
Arizona:  Toblerone
Arkansas: Skittles
California: Life Savers
Colorado: Milky Way
Connecticut: Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
Delaware: 3 Musketeers
Florida: Nestlé Crunch
Georgia – Pixy Stix
Hawaii: 100 Grand Bar
Idaho: Butterfinger
Illinois: Snickers
Indiana: Reese’s Pieces
Iowa: Twix
Kansas: Twizzlers
Kentucky: Whoppers
Louisiana: Swedish Fish
Maine: Starburst
Maryland: Almond Joy
Massachusetts: Starburst
Michigan: M&M’s
Minnesota: 100 Grand Bar
Mississippi: Hershey’s Kisses
Missouri: Hershey’s Kisses
Montana: Kit Kat
Nebraska: Skittles
Nevada: Jolly Ranchers
New Hampshire: Tootsie Rolls
New Jersey: Sour Patch Kids
New Mexico: 3 Musketeers
New York: Sweetarts
North Carolina: Butterfinger
North Dakota: Sour Patch Kids
Ohio: Milky Way
Oklahoma: M&M’s
Oregon: Candy corn
Pennsylvania: Swedish Fish
Rhode Island: Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
South Carolina: Candy corn
South Dakota: Laffy Taffy
Tennessee: Candy corn
Texas: Candy corn
Utah: Nerds
Vermont: Almond Joy
Virginia: Reese’s Pieces
Washington: AirHeads
West Virginia: Oreos
Wisconsin: Laffy Taffy
Wyoming: Candy corn
District of Columbia: Twix